YspeopleExplore tab

I hate to rain on Mother Nature's parade ...


About Philosophically

I think, therefore I am.


"There is no such thing as nature"

Man-made concepts like "nature" contribute nothing. And here's why.

Nature is not a living being, or entity.

Nature is not a living being, or entity. It just is, writes Philosophically Yours. Picture: istock

During a conversation about the fascinating habits of bees and some of the apparently inexplicable aspects of their behaviour, a friend recently suggested that "nature works in mysterious ways".

Borrowing from the expression "God moves in mysterious ways", this concerned me greatly, not just because I struggle with the concept of God, but more so because I struggle with the concept of nature.

Who or what is nature?

People often talk about nature as if it is a being, as reflected in phrases like "nature does not hurry, yet everything is accomplished". Very often people talk about nature almost as if it were a human being, referring to Mother Nature.

Read more fro Philosophically Yours: Without morals, we are nothing

They refer to nature as if it is a life force or superhuman force that determines what happens in the world, as reflected in phrases like "nature is the art of god".

There are so many phrases attributed to some of humanity's most famous names that humanise or super-humanise nature, presenting it as some form of life force.

Ralph Waldo Emmerson famously said: "Nature always wears the colours of the spirit". Albert Einstein said: "Joy is looking and comprehending nature’s most beautiful gifts". William Wordsworth wrote: "Nature never did betray the heart that loved her".

The facts are, that there is no being, or superbeing, to wear anything Mr Emmerson; there is nothing to offer gifts, Professor Einstein; and there's no ‘her’ to love, Mr Wordsworth.

Nature is not a being, or even a superbeing. Nature is not a life force, or a force of any kind. Nature is not a him, or her. Nature is not alive or dead. There is no such thing as nature.

Nature is a human construct developed to help explain what we humans struggle with. It is not dissimilar to the concept of a god and may well be an extension of that concept. Sir Thomas Browne even suggested that "nature is the art of god".

Contrary to what many suggest, nature did not create mankind (any more than God did). Mankind created the notion of nature. Nature was not responsible for natural selection. Natural selection just happened. Nature was no more responsible for some aspects of our planet working well (like symbiotic relationships) than it is for those aspects that do not work well (like worms that eat the eye from the inside out)

But why is this important? Why is it important that we jettison this concept of nature as a force?

Because the notion of nature as a force, being or even superbeing underpins the notion that some things are natural and other things are not. If there is no ‘nature’ then nothing can be natural and suggesting that some things are natural while other things are unnatural is unhelpful in the extreme.

Disasters are often described by human beings as an "act of nature". There are no acts of nature because there is no nature. There is no force or life force that causes these things to occur, they just occur – sometimes with human input and, sometimes, without.

Many people have suggested that homosexuality is not natural. The fact is, however, that it is neither natural or unnatural. There is no nature and, as such, nothing is natural or unnatural. Natural and unnatural are human constructs, just as nature is a human construct.

People talk fatalistically about the rich and poor in our community, describing the current situation as the "natural order of things". There is no natural order because there is no nature. In this regard, there is only what man creates.

All notions of fate, determinism and karma are predicated on a "natural order of things". But there is no nature and, as such, there is no natural order of things. There is no fate or karma – but that is a discussion for another day!

Nothing is natural, or unnatural – it just is!

This is the fifth in a series of missives addressing quotes relevant to all our lives in the 21st century.

Banner 1
| Your rating
No ratings yet


Related stories

His Holiness the Dalai Lama.

The power of the null hypothesis

I am a big subscriber to the null hypothesis, a scientific term suggesting there is no evidence available to you that enables...

Expand
About 1 year ago
(Headlines)
Why is the Church obsessed with sex? Picture: Shutterstock.

The plebiscite and the Christian obsession with sex

Why does this most natural of human pursuits cause so much division?

LGBTI Politics Marriage Equality Australia
Expand
About 1 year ago
(Headlines)
Let's do this! Picture: Shutterstock.

Calling out the Coalition For Marriage for what it is

 

The Coalition For Marriage's action against the gay community this week is no different to an old-fashioned religious witch hunt.

LGBTI Politics Marriage Equality Australia
Expand
About 1 year ago
(Headlines)
All power to a truthful ABC.

Why One Nation's push against the ABC is wrong

The ABC has a responsibility to report the facts, not a balanced view.

Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
What do you think of Australia day? Picture: ABC.

Australia Day: Is January 26 appropriate?

What are your thoughts on an appropriate date to celebrate Australia Day? Here are mine.

Community Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
Is prison an ineffective deterrent? Please share your thoughts with us.

Why do we jail offenders?

Retribution is not, and should not, be the primary purpose of imprisonment.

Community Social Issues
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
United, we CAN make a difference to our world.

Together, the over-50s can change the world

 

I am an Australian over the age of 50. I believe together we must stand, or divided we will fall.

Ageing Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
Peter Finch in that rousing scene from Network.

I'm as mad as hell. Come yell with me!

It's time to stand up and tell our politicians that we are as mad as hell and not going to take it anymore.

Movies Community Social Issues Politics
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
How can PM Malcolm Turnbull truly understand the average Australian? Picture: iStock.

Does Malcolm Turnbull understand you?

How can anyone truly understand you until they have walked a mile in your shoes?

Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
Wooden, and full of half-truths and tall tales .

Political integrity? Pffft, you've got to be joking!

Don't you just hate politicians who think you are too thick to realise they are just telling you what you want to hear?

Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)

Message board

Derek, 5 months ago:
I am great
George, 5 months ago:
What's up Thomas?
George, 5 months ago:
Messages are now updated in real time on other browsers.
Thomas, 5 months ago:
Hello
Thomas, 6 months ago:
Great!
DJC, 6 months ago:
Groovy!
George, 6 months ago:
Message board active from June 2018

Have your say!

Your Great Australians

Trending stories
Blue Moraine Lake in Banff, Canada.

Some stunning Earth porn to brighten your day

A reminder of how...

(Travel) 10 months ago
When it comes to great bloggers you can connect with, this list has you covered.

20 mature bloggers worth following

Looking for Australian...

(Entertainment & Culture) Over 1 year ago
Roger Federer - a gentleman and a thinker.

Roger Federer proves that wisdom aces youth

Age takes much away, but it...

(Sport & Leisure) Over 1 year ago
Italian food.

Great Italian delights

The integrity that is...

(Epicure) 7 months ago
I hated school, but felt free during the daily walk there and back.

Do you remember walking to school?

Walking the few kilometres...

(Nostalgia) 8 months ago
Weekly Poll
Photographic memories
Hizgg0vzzqvwc9xicknk
It's 35 years since the Ash Wednesday bushfires in South Australia and Victoria claimed 75 lives and more than 2500 buildings.