YspeopleExplore tab

Where is the evidence?

About Philosophically

I think, therefore I am.

‘Nothing is more bizarre than believing in God’

Let me declare myself: I am not an atheist. I am quite prepared to believe in God. But at the same time, I am not agnostic. I am not of two minds about the existence of God. I am certainly not a believer. I see nothing to believe in.

But where is the evidence, asks Philosophically Yours.

But where is the evidence, asks Philosophically Yours. Picture: iStock

Surely it is not possible to think objectively and critically, and still believe in God.

For me, it all comes down to evidence. In the absence of any, there is nothing for me to believe in, be in two minds about, or disbelieve. 

If presented with any evidence at all, I would be prepared to enter the debate about the existence of God. In the absence of any, I view a belief in God nothing short of bizarre – as is the suggestion that the Bible is evidence.

A book is never evidence of anything. A book can, at best, be a record of evidence - and having read the Bible, I am apprised of no evidence whatsoever. It is more or less a document that has been translated and altered many times, which reflects the stories and attitudes of a time.

I have already written on my view that none of us choose what we believe and, as such, while we can and should be held responsible for our behaviour, we should never be held responsible for our beliefs. Our beliefs differ from person to person, place to place and time to time because we've all had different upbringings with different stimuli causing different beliefs.

Indeed, this is why the followers of every faith are as convinced that every other faith is wrong as they are that their faith is right. There are also the feebleminded in every faith that say they ‘know’ there is a God. This is no more or less bizarre than saying that one ‘knows;’ there is no God. There is no evidence required to know anything of the sort. We can at best ‘believe’ what we believe.

I, for one, know and believe nothing. What is more, I have no driving force to do either. I am quite comfortable with the fact that people die, have no fear of my own death and see little, if any, merit in everlasting life. I have no need to believe in a supernatural being and even if I did, needing something does not make it so. I can think of nothing positive that religion has done for the world. Morality existed before religion, there are plenty of immoral churches and believers, and there are as many non-religious charities as religious ones.

I have seen nothing that cannot be explained without the need for a god, and many things that cannot be explained with the existence of a god.

The Bible, and indeed most religions, suggest that God is all powerful (he can do anything), all loving (he loves all living things and in particular mankind – which was apparently created in his image) and all knowing (nothing slips his gaze).

This being the case, why do 10,000 children die every day in Africa from starvation? And it is not because of free will. 

Of course, there is also the notion that ‘God moves in mysterious ways’. This might well be the case, but it would be equally valid to say that ‘science or nature moves in mysterious ways’. Either way, this is not an argument with any merit whatsoever.

If you take offence from, or exception to, this missive, provide me with just one piece of evidence that there is a god and I will start looking harder for the rest.

But to quote Thomas Hardy, the son of a priest: “Ï have been looking for God all my life, but alas, I have not found him.'' Incidentally, Hardy said this in response to a priest suggesting he read him the last rights when he was on his death bed.

In the absence of any evidence at all, I view a belief in God as bizarre.

Banner 2
| Your rating
No ratings yet

Related stories

Women cheat on men who don't do house chores: study

Women are more likely to cheat on men who fail to pull their weight when it comes to household chores, according to a major...

Work Relationships
Originally from telegraph.co.uk
10 months ago
(Love & Relationships)
Marriage is a con, serving no purpose at all.

Marriage is a symptom of ugliness

Relationships and love have astonishing value. But marriage? Pffffft, what a con!

Relationships Community Social Issues
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
By following a few commonsense rules, online dating isn't so scary after all.

How to stay safe while dating online


Have you found yourself single again in midlife? Thinking about online dating? Read this first.

Relationships Technology Health
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
Saying thankyou will brighten two people's day.

The power of saying thankyou

There is incredible power in saying thankyou and expecting nothing in return.

Relationships Community Health
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
Grandkids say the funniest things.

The things your grandchildren say

Children say the darndest things, don't they? Share your funny anecdotes.

Relationships Community Humour
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
Children need to know it's OK to bite, kick and scream if grabbed by a stranger.

Nine life-saving lessons to teach your grandkids

Here's how to equip your grandchildren with the tools to keep them safe from predators.

Family Relationships Community Social Issues
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
We were like chalk and cheese.

An overdue apology to my long-dead brother

The pain following your death on that remote country road runs deep. Here's why I want to sorry.

Family Relationships Loss
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
A class divided passport of the 80s.

My passport is a snapshot of an uglier time


You only have to look at my passport from the 1980s -- which lists me as black and bans me from travelling to South Africa --...

Social Issues India Politics Australia
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
Empty nesters, how did you celebrate winning your freedom back? Picture: Shutterstock.

Empty nesters, let's hear your stories

Alright all of you empty nesters, how did you celebrate your new-found freedom? Let's get a conversation started.

Property Relationships Community
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
Baby Joyce.

Marriage meltdown not Barnaby’s only failure

Our Deputy PM's moral protestations about our interest in his love life go directly to the character of the man.

Relationships Social Issues Politics Australia
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)

Message board

Derek, 10 months ago:
I am great
George, 10 months ago:
What's up Thomas?
George, 10 months ago:
Messages are now updated in real time on other browsers.
Thomas, 10 months ago:
Thomas, 11 months ago:
DJC, 11 months ago:
George, 11 months ago:
Message board active from June 2018

Have your say!

Your Great Australians

Trending stories
When it comes to great bloggers you can connect with, this list has you covered.

20 mature bloggers worth following

Looking for Australian...

(Entertainment & Culture) About 2 years ago
They may be hideous, but geez, some toby jugs are valuable.

Is your toby jug worth a fortune?

Did you know that some of...

(Nostalgia) 10 months ago
The author believes the merger of many charities would be in the best interests of the needy.

Why do charities exist?

Should charities exist for...

(Kindness) Almost 2 years ago
The Australian Car.

Remembering the mighty Holden EH

While the EH Holden, even...

(Pastimes) 10 months ago
The Emirates first-class suite.

What it's really like to fly first class

Time literally flies when...

(Ys Comment) Over 1 year ago
Weekly Poll
Photographic memories
It's 35 years since the Ash Wednesday bushfires in South Australia and Victoria claimed 75 lives and more than 2500 buildings.