YspeopleExplore tab

Does Malcolm Turnbull understand you?




About DJC

The older I get, the less I know and the more inquisitive I get.

Unfortunately, despite a lifelong search, most of the answers elude me. That said, I love to ask the questions and fuel the debates that will ultimately lead us all to a better understanding of the big issues in life, the universe and everything.

They say that we spend 98% of our lives in our head. I for one would like to use that time as effectively as possible.


How can anyone truly understand you until they have walked a mile in your shoes?

During my years in advertising, I remember reading an interview with John Singleton, in which the highly successful Australia advertising legend noted that the problem with many advertising people is that they have no empathy for the people they are trying to communicate and engage with.

How can PM Malcolm Turnbull truly understand the average Australian? Picture: iStock.

How can PM Malcolm Turnbull truly understand the average Australian? Picture: iStock

To me, this makes very good sense and goes someway to explaining the low standard of advertising in this country. How can a single, university-educated, Porsche-driving creative director earning $250,000-plus understand a Commodore-driving meat worker who left school at 15 and will have to feed his family of five on $55,000 a year?

With much difficulty, I believe.

Perhaps the same question needs to be asked of Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull. How can a man born into affluence, who attended Sydney Grammar School, married into one of Australia’s establishment families and amassed a wealth of $300 million dollars - which includes a house in Point Piper valued at $50 million - possibly understand that meat worker, or any Australian on the average income of $67,000 per annum?

I don't believe he can.

I am not suggesting that Bill Shorten, Tony Abbott, or any of the other would-be prime ministers would understand any of us any better. I certainly feel no connection whatsoever to Bill Shorten, Tony Abbott or Richard De Natalie, for that matter. What I am arguing is that many politicians, particularly the very privileged and wealthy ones, have little chance of understanding the circumstances in which everyday Australians live.

As much as they are all given to say, ‘what Australians think is…’, or ‘What Australians want is…’ I believe they would have a limited understanding of either. Furthermore, no amount of market research or focus groups will deliver the required empathy. It may deliver a cognitive sensitivity, but it will never deliver an understanding empathy.

To a large extent, the only people that can understand you are those that have walked a mile in your shoes. John Singleton suggested that his ability to write advertisements such as those for VB was dependent on him standing in Bay 13 at the football, drinking VB and engaging with Collingwood supporters - not sitting in the corporate box.

As much as he seems to like public transport, I suspect Malcolm Turnbull is unlikely to spend an afternoon in Bay 13 at the MCG. How could he possibly have empathy for that meat worker,  you, or anyone who walks in shoes like yours. He cannot and does not!

Around the Cabinet room table and within the parliament there are many working with the Prime Minister with backgrounds different to his. That said, how many of them have backgrounds very similar to yours? How many of the politicians in the parliament have walked a mile in shoes anything like yours?

If these people have a poor understanding of you and little empathy for the circumstances in which you find yourself, how can they truly represent you, and to what extent can they only truly engage with people with backgrounds similar to their own? All people in all strata have their issues, and inevitably the issues we relate to most are those that we too have experienced.

So, what to do?

Well, you tell me!

How do we get a greater diversity of people into parliament?

There has been a lot of talk about getting more women into parliament, as there should be. There has been a lot of talk about getting more indigenous people into parliament, as there should be.

But what about getting more working-class people into parliament; and I don’t mean university-educated union representatives that have never been truly working class. I mean people who are truly working or middle class, who have walked a mile or two in shoes just like yours.

Banner 1
| Your rating
No ratings yet


Related stories

His Holiness the Dalai Lama.

The power of the null hypothesis

I am a big subscriber to the null hypothesis, a scientific term suggesting there is no evidence available to you that enables...

Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
Why is the Church obsessed with sex? Picture: Shutterstock.

The plebiscite and the Christian obsession with sex

Why does this most natural of human pursuits cause so much division?

LGBTI Politics Marriage Equality Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
Let's do this! Picture: Shutterstock.

Calling out the Coalition For Marriage for what it is

 

The Coalition For Marriage's action against the gay community this week is no different to an old-fashioned religious witch hunt.

LGBTI Politics Marriage Equality Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
All power to a truthful ABC.

Why One Nation's push against the ABC is wrong

The ABC has a responsibility to report the facts, not a balanced view.

Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
What do you think of Australia day? Picture: ABC.

Australia Day: Is January 26 appropriate?

What are your thoughts on an appropriate date to celebrate Australia Day? Here are mine.

Community Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
Is prison an ineffective deterrent? Please share your thoughts with us.

Why do we jail offenders?

Retribution is not, and should not, be the primary purpose of imprisonment.

Community Social Issues
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
United, we CAN make a difference to our world.

Together, the over-50s can change the world

 

I am an Australian over the age of 50. I believe together we must stand, or divided we will fall.

Ageing Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
Peter Finch in that rousing scene from Network.

I'm as mad as hell. Come yell with me!

It's time to stand up and tell our politicians that we are as mad as hell and not going to take it anymore.

Movies Community Social Issues Politics
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
Wooden, and full of half-truths and tall tales .

Political integrity? Pffft, you've got to be joking!

Don't you just hate politicians who think you are too thick to realise they are just telling you what you want to hear?

Social Issues Politics Australia
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)
The amount of unnecessary waste that comes from supermarket packaging is deplorable.

A pile of rubbish in my shopping

The packaging in your shopping pollutes the planet and adds little value to you, the consumer - so why not reject it?

Money Environment
Expand
Over 1 year ago
(Headlines)

Message board

Derek, 5 months ago:
I am great
George, 5 months ago:
What's up Thomas?
George, 5 months ago:
Messages are now updated in real time on other browsers.
Thomas, 5 months ago:
Hello
Thomas, 6 months ago:
Great!
DJC, 6 months ago:
Groovy!
George, 6 months ago:
Message board active from June 2018

Have your say!

Your Great Australians

Trending stories
When it comes to great bloggers you can connect with, this list has you covered.

20 mature bloggers worth following

Looking for Australian...

(Entertainment & Culture) Over 1 year ago
I'm a Christian and I think Christmas is bah humbug! Picture: Shutterstock.

Christmas is a sham!

Let me explain why, as a...

(Ys Comment) About 1 year ago
The author believes the merger of many charities would be in the best interests of the needy.

Why do charities exist?

Should charities exist for...

(Kindness) Over 1 year ago
Remember me?.

Can you guess who I am?

Can you work out who I am...

(Nostalgia) 10 months ago
Don Bradman - number 2?.

The poet who beat Don Bradman to No.1

When it comes to great...

(Entertainment & Culture) 10 months ago
Weekly Poll
Photographic memories
Hizgg0vzzqvwc9xicknk
It's 35 years since the Ash Wednesday bushfires in South Australia and Victoria claimed 75 lives and more than 2500 buildings.