YspeopleExplore tab

Help! I think I'm being catfished!

About The Midlife Single

Join me as I try to navigate the dating scene as a single, middle-aged woman. 

I have a gut feeling that I'm being catfished online by an ex. Here's my cautionary story!

Three weekends in to my online dating adventure and I fear I'm being catfished by an ex.

For those of you not familiar with the term catfishing, it refers to the sadly common practise of people pretending to be someone they're not, via false identities they've created on dating sites and/or social media, particularly to pursue deceptive online romances. 

What kind of lowlife has nothing better to do than catfish somebody.

What kind of lowlife has nothing better to do than catfish somebody. Picture: Shutterstock

It's generally regarded as the lowest form of behaviour. After all, it's fraud against those who are putting themselves out there while making themselves quite vulnerable. 

Read more from The Midlife Single: Let the dating adventures begin

But it is so common that an entire reality TV series was built around it, catching out an endless stream of fairly pathetic offenders on behalf of victims .

I thought I was too savvy to get stung. And while I have no solid evidence that I've been catfished, the gut feeling is intense on this one and if there's one thing I've learnt to rely on in life, it's my instinct.

It doesn't help that I met the ex in question, Mr G,  two years earlier on the same site ... ironically, called Plenty of Fish. We dated casually for a few months until I discovered I was his side piece, he'd been cheating on his partner of four years.

I had also stumbled across his profile again on the site the night before and swiped left with a shiver. Was it fair to assume that he'd also seen my newly created one?

The unsettling scenario unfolded the next day, on the Sunday, when I broke my golden rule about not engaging in conversation with anyone whose dating profile did not carry a photograph.

5 Craziest Catfish Stories Ever!

For me, a lack of photo is the first solid indication that a person has something to hide.

But this guy caught me on the hop. I was having a lovely chat with a sweet but cheeky gent on Plenty Of Fish when the suspected offender's first message landed.

It was from a user called The Argentine Devil.

I didn't give it a second glance. However, about an hour later, while waiting for a reply to a message from my new friend, I got bored and scrolled down through my inbox.

There it was, The Argentine Devil , enticing me like a red rag would a bull. I'm a creature with a curious mind and a weakness for a sexy accent, so it was no surprise when I convinced myself it wouldn't hurt to look.

His introduction of himself was direct and to the point: Would I consider dating a well-built man from overseas?

Curiosity satisfied, I ignored the message and carried on. But a seed had been planted.

A little later, for reasons I cannot explain, I jumped back in to read his profile properly. Surprisingly, his profile was a polar opposite to his username. He did not come across as a jerk or a sleeze, but a divorcee looking to date, ultimately long-term.

I replied to his message, thanking him for saying hello but declining because of the lack of the photo.  

Long story short, we ended up chatting ... probably a little too easily now that I think back on it. 

He said his name was Andre, that he was Argentinean-Australian and manager, who did not need staff prying into his business. He then posted a couple of photos of a handsome, exotic-looking fellow (probably my ex's salsa instructor, poor sod) and I ignored the alarm bells ringing in my head.

A couple of hours down the track after some comfortable and sometimes spirited banter, Andre thanked me for the chat and said he had to go.

Just 15 minutes later, a petulant Mr G messaged me on WatsApp, wanting to know if we could catch up, saying that he missed me, asking why he was not a priority in my life any more and making a cryptic reference to goldfish.

Coincidence?  I don't think so! But again, I have no proof, just an extremely strong suspicion.

It was strong enough that I've deleted him from WhatsApp (I'd unfriended him on Facebook and deleted his phone number long ago). I've also reported the Andre profile to Plenty of Fish, explaining my fears - apologising if I'm, in fact, wrong -  but explaining that if I'm correct, the psycho needed to be stopped from hurting anyone else.

Meanwhile, I'm scratching my head about what else I could have done, bar engaging again with a toxic narcissist and not having concrete proof to back my instinct.

I'd love to hear what you think. Ám I right to have my suspicions? Should I have tackled this situation differently? And most importantly, what would you have done? 

Even worse, have you had a close encounter with a Catfish?

Please, get in touch. I'm dying to hear from you.

Banner 1
| Your rating
No ratings yet

Related stories

Women cheat on men who don't do house chores: study

Women are more likely to cheat on men who fail to pull their weight when it comes to household chores, according to a major...

Work Relationships
Originally from telegraph.co.uk
11 months ago
(Love & Relationships)
Marriage is a con, serving no purpose at all.

Marriage is a symptom of ugliness

Relationships and love have astonishing value. But marriage? Pffffft, what a con!

Relationships Community Social Issues
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
By following a few commonsense rules, online dating isn't so scary after all.

How to stay safe while dating online


Have you found yourself single again in midlife? Thinking about online dating? Read this first.

Relationships Technology Health
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
Saying thankyou will brighten two people's day.

The power of saying thankyou

There is incredible power in saying thankyou and expecting nothing in return.

Relationships Community Health
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
Grandkids say the funniest things.

The things your grandchildren say

Children say the darndest things, don't they? Share your funny anecdotes.

Relationships Community Humour
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
Children need to know it's OK to bite, kick and scream if grabbed by a stranger.

Nine life-saving lessons to teach your grandkids

Here's how to equip your grandchildren with the tools to keep them safe from predators.

Family Relationships Community Social Issues
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
We were like chalk and cheese.

An overdue apology to my long-dead brother

The pain following your death on that remote country road runs deep. Here's why I want to sorry.

Family Relationships Loss
About 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
A class divided passport of the 80s.

My passport is a snapshot of an uglier time


You only have to look at my passport from the 1980s -- which lists me as black and bans me from travelling to South Africa --...

Social Issues India Politics Australia
Over 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
Empty nesters, how did you celebrate winning your freedom back? Picture: Shutterstock.

Empty nesters, let's hear your stories

Alright all of you empty nesters, how did you celebrate your new-found freedom? Let's get a conversation started.

Property Relationships Community
Over 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)
Baby Joyce.

Marriage meltdown not Barnaby’s only failure

Our Deputy PM's moral protestations about our interest in his love life go directly to the character of the man.

Relationships Social Issues Politics Australia
Over 1 year ago
(Love & Relationships)

Message board

Derek, 11 months ago:
I am great
George, 11 months ago:
What's up Thomas?
George, 11 months ago:
Messages are now updated in real time on other browsers.
Thomas, 11 months ago:
Thomas, 12 months ago:
DJC, 12 months ago:
George, 12 months ago:
Message board active from June 2018

Have your say!

Your Great Australians

Trending stories
When it comes to great bloggers you can connect with, this list has you covered.

20 mature bloggers worth following

Looking for Australian...

(Entertainment & Culture) About 2 years ago
They may be hideous, but geez, some toby jugs are valuable.

Is your toby jug worth a fortune?

Did you know that some of...

(Nostalgia) 11 months ago
JB Hi-Fi is on the money when it comes to customer service.

JB Hi-Fi Vs Harvey Norman

When it comes to comparing...

(Money & Business) Over 2 years ago
Baby Boomer men are having more unsafe sex than their younger counterparts.

Why are many older men so stupid about sex?

Baby Boomers are much more...

(Love & Relationships) Over 1 year ago
These brownies just get better with age.

Rachel's 'liberated' brownies


(Epicure) Almost 2 years ago
Weekly Poll
Photographic memories
It's 35 years since the Ash Wednesday bushfires in South Australia and Victoria claimed 75 lives and more than 2500 buildings.