YspeopleExplore tab


He won a Nobel Prize for proving what we know

Thumb mystery man on the phone

About James

I have lived a lot of years and the more years I have lived, the fewer answers i have found. I hope that by engaging here we can discover some answers together.

Don't you just love people with the courage to challenge the status quo?

Richard Thaler, of the Stern School of Business at Chicago University, won the Nobel Prize for Economics this month. Since I've read much of his work and followed him online for some time, I was quite pleased

Why buy a Ferrari? Picture: Shutterstock.

Why buy a Ferrari? Picture: Shutterstock

Thaler is clearly a brilliant man. Forbes magazine labelled him the most important economist of his era.

So what was his contribution?

Well, Thaler proved that people are not rational. Of course, we all know intuitively that the people around us are not rational, but it turns out that neither are we. Further, the economic and general definitions of ‘rational’ are not exactly the same.

Read more James St James: Can you live without airconditioning?

In general conversation, rational means logical or unemotional – summing up the facts and making a considered choice. Rational in an economic context involves ‘making the choice that will deliver the optimal level of benefit or utility to the individual’.

While there is some crossover in these two definitions, rational in an economic context is much more than logic. Judgments about whether a decision is rational in an economic sense requires knowing what is being purchased.

For example, buying a Ferrari to drive to and from work is hardly logical if you live in a crowded city. A Ferrari performs badly at low speed and this can damage the vehicle. Ferraris are not especially comfortable cars, specially when you are stuck in traffic. It also seems illogical to buy a car that can get up to speeds of 400km/hr and never be able to try it out.

Of course, all of this assumes that the owner of the vehicle is buying a car. As a car, it is not a logical purchase, but as a status symbol, it may well be a logical or even optimal purchase. Everybody knows what it is, they know it is expensive and they know the driver can afford one. As a means of acquiring status, the perception of success and attracting the opposite gender, a Ferrari may well ‘deliver optimal benefit or utility to the individual’.

This is a critically important issue, as all, or most of the laws of classical or traditional economics are predicated on human beings behaving rationally, at least in an economic sense. Thaler is threatening the very foundations of economics – and, as such, has attracted his share of detractors

So, of what value is knowing that human beings are not rational in the general and economic meanings of the word?

To start with, Thaler’s theories are not accepted by all. There are many academic economists that still maintain that it is safe to assume that decisions made by all consumers are rational – at least in an economic context. There are any number of traditional economists that spurn Thaler's work.

The fact is, however, whether or not the conclusion he has drawn about humans not making decisions that are rational in an economic sense, his considerable research has uncovered a wide range of truths that have been very helpful to business, governments and the community as a whole.

In research undertaken in Europe, Thaler demonstrated the power of opting out over opting in. This was found to be most useful in terms of organ donation rates. He found that in countries where people had to opt out of being an organ donor, the rates of donation were significantly higher, than in countries where there was an opt-in (yes, I want to donate) system. This study has since been validated.

There are those who would say that this does not prove consumers are behaving irrationally in an economic sense, but it certainly demonstrates that they are behaving irrationally in a general sense. Traditional economists might say that opting in requires more work and that explains the lower rates.

Thaler found that you can increase demand for a product by increasing its price. The increased price can, if managed well, increase the perception of value and prestige, and, as such, increase demand. Classical economics would suggest, based on the laws of supply and demand, that increasing prices should lower demand.

Some traditional economists would still argue that this is not absolute proof that people have behaved irrationally in an economic sense, although it is clearly irrational in a general sense. It is also a useful finding for marketers.

Thaler cites research that shows that offered one chocolate today or two chocolates tomorrow, most people (around 70 percent) choose one chocolate today. This has been verified many times. But if the same people are offered one chocolate in a year's time or two chocolates in a year and a day, the vast majority (perhaps 70 percent) will select the two chocolates.

In another study, people offered a $100 discount on a $1000 suit would travel significantly further than for $100 off a $50,000 car. But why? The fact is, $100 is $100 no matter how expensive the product is.

In both cases, human beings consistently behave irrationally.

Again, some defensive economists may suggest that this does not satisfy the requirements of being economically irrational, but I would argue that it satisfies both definitions of irrational.

It has also provided great data for businesses and governments developing marketing strategies.

My points here are two-fold.

Firstly, the work of Nobel Prize winners, while often not well understood, is often much more practical than many people think.

Secondly, Richard Thaler is a worthy winner, if only because he is testing a classical view of economics that has been around for eons and has not always provided the most reliable predictions. 

Don't you just love people with the courage to challenge the status quo?

Banner 1
| Your rating
No ratings yet

Related stories

Changing Australia Day from January 26 harms no one, but includes many.

Nobody suffers if we shift Australia Day celebrations

Why our Prime Minister's Australia Day stance is dishonest, divisive and wrong.

Politics Community Australia Day Australia
About 13 hours ago
(Ys Comment)
Note the shoes, bags and foodstuffs dumped in the William St doorway on the right.

Will anyone fix the social issues in the City of Perth?

Thieves, derelicts, druggies, public urinators, illegal parkers and beggars ... oh the daily joys of working in the city of Perth.

Politics Western Australia Social Issues
1 day ago
(Ys Comment)
Separation of powers is about keeping the bastards honest.

Keep politics out of policing and our courts

Our federal politicians have been dancing on dangerous, sacrosanct ground when it comes to policing and our judiciary -- and it...

Social Issues Politics Australia Community
3 days ago
(Ys Comment)
The chances of you falling victim to a violent crime are much lower than you've come to expect.

Are you living in fear of crime? Read on

What's your risk of falling a victim to a violent crime in Australia -- and are rates truly rising? You'll be shocked at the...

Social Issues Australia Community
7 days ago
(Ys Comment)
Be sure that the children in your life are learning the right lessons from you.

What are we teaching our children?

I guess this father never asked himself what lessons he was teaching his son that morning.

Community Social Issues Relationships
8 days ago
(Ys Comment)
Donald Trump has declared himself a genius.

Can you identify a genius?

Just what qualifies as genius? It's certainly not Tiger Woods, Paul McCartney or, shock horror, Donald Trump.

Culture Business Sport Celebrities
9 days ago
(Ys Comment)
Are you tired of armchair activists? (Image: Shutterstock).

Is social media killing activism?

Does making a comment actually make a difference?

Activism Social Media
14 days ago
(Ys Comment)
learning facts is of limited value (Image: Shutterstock).

The end of education as we know it

Is our current educational system outdated?

Society Education
15 days ago
(Ys Comment)
What are your intentions for the new year? (Image: Shutterstock).

Forget resolutions, create intentions

Do you make New Year's Resolutions? I don't. Read why making 'intentions' are better than resolutions here.

Goals Wellbeing New Year 2018
16 days ago
(Ys Comment)
Amazon is here to stay, so let's embrace it (Image: Shutterstock).

Amazon will improve our lives

Even offline shoppers will benefit. To start with department stores will go broke and gradually be replaced with customer...

Culture Technology Shopping
16 days ago
(Ys Comment)
Trending stories
If you look after your digestive health, life will be much sweeter for you and yours.

A happy gut equals a happy life

Nobody wants gut-health...

(Epicure) 4 days ago
Spend time with your friends!.

10 powerful tips for self-investment

When we prioritise...

(Health & Beauty) 4 days ago
Corporal punishment was all the rage when I was at school.

Do you remember the cane and strap?

It doesn't seem that long...

(Nostalgia) 4 days ago
Weekly Poll
Haiku of the week
Memory lane