YspeopleExplore tab

We must stop funding non-government schools

Thumb angry biker showing middle finger with both hands 000078716059 small

About Subversive

Do you have your own gripe with your local or state government? And what are the streets like in your part of town, in your home state?

If you'd like me to fire a rocket up them, or a shoddy business, I'm listening! You can email me here.

There shoud be no government funding of private schools. And here's why!

I don’t care whether they call themselves independent schools, private schools, or, as the British call them, public schools -- non-government schools in Australia should not be funded by the government.

Why should taxpayers fund educating the elite? Picture: Shutterstock .

Why should taxpayers fund educating the elite? Picture: Shutterstock

As I recall, it was the Whitlam Government that first provided significant funding from the public purse to private schools in Australia. While governments since then have varied the criteria and amount of funding for non-government schools, they continue to do so at significant levels.

While I am a fan of the vision of Gough Whitlam, I believe his policies in this respect were wrong. In my humble view, there should be no government funding of non-government schools. If parents choose to send their children to a non-government school, they should pay the full cost.

Read more from Subversive Sam: Over 50? We're the invisible generation

While I am aware this is a controversial stand, it's one I'm absolutely committed to. Taxpayers should not be funding non-government schools -- and I am considering starting a long-term campaign that would lead to this becoming the norm.

My father, a one-time school teacher, once said to me that while the government subsidises public transport (buses, trams and trains) it does not do the same for taxis. Taxis are a private mode of transport and should be fully funded by the user.

I believe this is a valid metaphor for what should happen in the education system.

I am aware that the counter-argument is that if the parents of non-government schoolchildren pay their taxes, they should have their education subsidised as well. 

I totally agree, so long as their children access these services in the manner that government provides it to all. All children that attend a government school receive access to roughly the same investment by government.

Catch the bus and you get a subsidy, catch a taxi and you don’t. Attend a government school and receive the subsidy, attend a non-government school and you don’t.

I know there is an argument about choice. Parents should be free to make the choice they believe is best for them and their children.

I agree, so long as they are prepared to pay for it. I have the right to buy a Rolls-Royce and might do so, if I had the money. Up until recently, if you purchased a locally made car you knew it was subsidised, while the imported vehicle was not. That is gone now, as it should be.

I know there will be arguments about religious freedom.

I agree that religious freedom is important, but it is the responsibility of parents to indoctrinate children, not the school system. If parents want the school to do it, they should pay for it, just as they pay for a taxi.

Working for elite non-government schools, I have surveyed many hundreds of parents of non-government schoolchildren, only to find myself disgusted by many of the reasons cited by these parents for sending their children to these schools.

These reasons have included: ‘babysitting’ before and after school hours; providing the discipline that the parents didn't have time to provide; facilitating connections and relationships that will help them in business; religious education; ‘making a man' of their boys; and personal prestige. So many were concerned about prestige.

Education  -- and the erroneous view that private schools offer a superior standard of education (look at the statistics) -- were secondary factors. Further, however, I would argue that the factors listed in the previous paragraph are more important to parents and are not the responsibility of the government.

Government has a responsibility to provide the best possible education to the greatest possible number of people, and this obligation is best served by concentrating as much money as possible on larger-scale hubs that can maximise the return on investment.

This will be best achieved by concentrating funds on public centres of excellence. Fragmenting the funding, as occurs now, is far from cost effective.

I know many readers will disagree with me and I would really like to hear from them.

Banner 1
| Your rating
No ratings yet

Related stories

Embrace training to stay relevant in an ever-changing workplace.

How to stay relevant at work


Companies are moving toward automation over human skills. Here's what you need to do to stay relevant at work.

Money Work
14 days ago
(Ys Comment)
That desperation to ''know'' and be right can cause so much unnecessary conflict.

When 'knowing' is dangerous


Nothing starts more conflict than people ''knowing'' stuff.

Politics Community Philosophy
4 months ago
(Ys Comment)
Do you trust politicians? Picture: Shutterstock.

Why don’t we trust politicians?

Here are my top five reasons that politicians are not trusted -- and they all relate to behaviour.

Australia Social Issues Politics
4 months ago
(Ys Comment)
Who is going to make their country better for their children, if they don’t? Picture: Shutterstock.

The real refugee question

All three of the common arguments against refugees have ignorance at their root. But there is one question yet to be addressed.

Australia Middle East Politics Social Issues
4 months ago
(Ys Comment)
Lines of people wait to collect natural spring water for drinking during the Cape Town drought.

Water: a crisis in the making

Cape Town is about to run out of water -- and 11 other major cities are facing the same plight. Horrifying, isn't it?

Australia Travel Environment
4 months ago
(Ys Comment)
PM Malcolm Turnbull attends another military show of strength.

Why the obsession with war?

Why we must rethink our view of the military -- and care more for our returned soldiers.

Community Australia Politics
5 months ago
(Ys Comment)
Finding your mythical purpose.

Perhaps it's your 'fate' to read this post

Why it pays to create your own purpose ... and other philosophical musings.

Community Phhilosophy
5 months ago
(Ys Comment)
We have a beautiful country but is our national anthem accurate? (Image: Shutterstock).

Australia's national anthem a disappointment


As far as national anthems go, Advance Australia Fair fails to mean much to me. Here's why.

History Culture Australia
5 months ago
(Ys Comment)
Boofhead and Moralising.

F**k boofhead Barnaby and moralising Malcolm

The grubbiness of the Barnaby Joyce affair shows there is pain ahead for many, including the good voters of Australia.

Social Issues Relationships Australia Politics
5 months ago
(Ys Comment)
Shop safely from the comfort of home by following these simple rules.

Shop safely online with these simple rules


Wondering what all the fuss is about with online shopping, but scared of being ripped off? Don't worry, we'll steer you right.

Technology Money
6 months ago
(Ys Comment)

Message board

Derek, 14 days ago:
I am great
George, 14 days ago:
What's up Thomas?
George, 15 days ago:
Messages are now updated in real time on other browsers.
Thomas, 15 days ago:
Thomas, about 1 month ago:
DJC, about 1 month ago:
George, about 2 months ago:
Message board active from June 2018

Have your say!

Your Great Australians

Trending stories
When it comes to great bloggers you can connect with, this list has you covered.

20 mature bloggers worth following

Looking for Australian...

(Entertainment & Culture) Over 1 year ago
Many people let desire for something, such as a god, colour their assessment of the evidence.

Try wishing upon a proven star

''Never let a wish become...

(Headlines) Over 1 year ago
Drizzle some maple syrup and your pancakes with bacon are good to go.

Mapled pancakes with organic bacon

C'Mon! You know you want to...

(Epicure) About 1 year ago
Who's worse, member unions or business? Picture: Supplied.

Are unions as bad as business?

Employer unions, employee...

14 days ago
She truly does love, honour and obey Jim.

Jim really does spank his wife often

Part two in the story of...

(Love & Relationships) 8 months ago
Weekly Poll
Photographic memories
It's 35 years since the Ash Wednesday bushfires in South Australia and Victoria claimed 75 lives and more than 2500 buildings.