YspeopleExplore tab

Who would you employ?

About DJC

The older I get, the less I know and the more inquisitive I get.

Unfortunately, despite a lifelong search, most of the answers elude me. That said, I love to ask the questions and fuel the debates that will ultimately lead us all to a better understanding of the big issues in life, the universe and everything.

They say that we spend 98% of our lives in our head. I for one would like to use that time as effectively as possible.

Two terrific candidates, one correct answer to a question. But who I'd choose is not who you'd think.

I first heard this story told by Neil deGrasse Tyson, one of the world’s greatest contemporary physicists.

Who would you employ? Picture: Shutterstock.

Who would you employ? Picture: Shutterstock

As he tells it, a university professor is interviewing two candidates for a job at the university. With a view to gaining meaningful insights into the thinking of the candidates and thus, their suitability to the job, he asked them both a series of questions, the last of which was: ''How tall is the spire on the top of this building?''

The first candidate answered the question by suggesting that he had an interest in architectural history and, as a result, had studied all the spires in the town. He remembered reading that the spire on the building was 155m high. He was precisely correct.

The second candidate said she had no knowledge but, given a moment, would offer an estimate. She then went outside, paced out the length of the spire shadow, then measured the length of her shadow from the same point and, using ratios, estimated that the spire was 150m high. She was 5m off.

Based on this question alone, who would you hire?

Would you employ the candidate with the good memory, or the candidate with the skills to estimate with a high degree of accuracy?

While such a decision should never be based on the answer to just one question -- and we have no knowledge of the nature of the job, and whether an interest in architecture is an advantage -- on the basis of this question and these responses, I would employ the candidate who worked out the answer.

Tyson makes the point that, setting aside its imperfections, this story addresses a critical issue -- namely the distinction between a candidate who can remember and a candidate who can think. Else>>>oadly, it looks at the relative importance of knowledge, and the capacity to think.

I would back the candidate who can think over one who just knows, every time! Knowledge based on study is important, but it is much less important than the capacity to work through the problem, even if the outcome is less precise. What if the question related to the height of a spire that the candidate had not memorised? The second candidate would still have been able to provide an estimate, while the first would be stumped.

The capacity to think and work through problems is almost always more useful that the ability to remember. Consider, for example, the changing job market. The candidate who has memorised facts relevant to a particular job will be unemployed when that job no longer exists. On the other hand, the candidate who can think through issues will be more able to think through the challenges of the new job.

In some instances, immediately accessible knowledge is important, but in most cases the ability to think through issues, whatever the issue, is far more important, particularly in the longer term.

This being the case, it is important to ask about the priorities of our education system. I believe that learning multiplication tables and maths formulas by rote is about knowledge, while learning how to work out mathematical challenges is about thinking. I also believe the primary focus of our education system is knowledge, not thinking.

This is why, in the course of a day, I meet so few people who can think. They all know stuff, or think they do, but few of them can work issues through by applying objective, critical and even socratic thinking. Most people I know rely on facts learned, to avoid having to think, even though the facts are so often out of date or even irrelevant.

Bertrand Russell once said: ''Most people would rather die than think…..and most people do.''

Sometimes this is because they are lazy, others it is because they lack the ability. Very often it is because they don’t know how, as the result of the people in their life placing a higher priority on knowledge than thinking. 

What do you think?

Banner 2
| Your rating
No ratings yet

Related stories

Do you have a canny tip for saving money.

Share your money-saving hacks here

Everyone loves to save a dollar or two when they can. Do you have any money-saving tips to share with your YsFriends?

5 months ago
(Money & Business)
Because you're never too old to pursue your passion.

Your midlife career-switch advice is golden

Have you started a new business or pulled off a major career switch in midlife? We'd love to hear from you.

Ageing Money
5 months ago
(Money & Business)
Rejuvenate in Retirement.

6 ways to retire from work, not life


Are you ready for The Lifestyle Change? Retirement can be a more difficult adjustment than we realise.

Retirement Health Relationships Money Ageing
5 months ago
(Money & Business)
James Packer: born with a silver spoon in his mouth.

Bring back death duties for silver spooners

Why should the privileged offspring of Australia's elite inherit their billions tax-free? Let's level the playing field.

Business Ageing Money
6 months ago
(Money & Business)
Retirees have copped a rough time in recent years.

A new approach to retirement planning

I’m going to stick my neck out just a bit and say retirees have had a raw deal over the past couple of decades.

Ageing Retirement Money
6 months ago
(Money & Business)
Funeral directors prey on the vulnerable.

Funeral directors are blood-sucking leeches

Leveraging grief to up-sell expensive funerals to vulnerable families is a loathsome practise and must stop.

Money Business Community Family
6 months ago
(Money & Business)
Trickle-down economics my arse.

How big business is giving you the shaft

Are you battling to make ends meet thanks to stagnant wages and lack of jobs? Here's who's to blame.

Politics Social Issues Community Business Money
6 months ago
(Money & Business)
What impact will the eventual death of Queen Elizabeth have on us in Australia?.

What happens to us when the Queen dies?


As a part of the Commonwealth, the impact on Australia will be greater than you think.

UK Australia Community Social Issues Politics
6 months ago
(Money & Business)
Myer - no Harrods.

Good riddance to Myer's CEO!

And there are plenty more who should follow him. Don't these obscene executive salaries make you furious?

Business Money
6 months ago
(Money & Business)
New CBA CEO Matt Comyn.

Why 'banker' should start with a W

It's our fault that the big banks treat us with such contempt and arrogance. Time to hit back by taking our mortgages and...

Community Money Business
6 months ago
(Money & Business)

Message board

Derek, about 1 month ago:
I am great
George, about 1 month ago:
What's up Thomas?
George, about 1 month ago:
Messages are now updated in real time on other browsers.
Thomas, about 1 month ago:
Thomas, 2 months ago:
DJC, 2 months ago:
George, 3 months ago:
Message board active from June 2018

Have your say!

Your Great Australians

Trending stories
When it comes to great bloggers you can connect with, this list has you covered.

20 mature bloggers worth following

Looking for Australian...

(Entertainment & Culture) Over 1 year ago
Suzuki's cute little Ignis SUV has a lot going for it.

Review: 2017 Suzuki Ignis GL and GLX

Japanese car maker Suzuki,...

(Pastimes) About 1 year ago
JB Hi-Fi is on the money when it comes to customer service.

JB Hi-Fi Vs Harvey Norman

When it comes to comparing...

(Money & Business) Over 1 year ago

Ripper dad jokes get a laugh

Here's my pick of some of...

(Love & Relationships) Almost 2 years ago
Embrace training to stay relevant in an ever-changing workplace.

How to stay relevant at work

Companies are moving toward...

(Ys Comment) About 1 month ago
Weekly Poll
Photographic memories
It's 35 years since the Ash Wednesday bushfires in South Australia and Victoria claimed 75 lives and more than 2500 buildings.