YspeopleExplore tab

How Turnbull sacrificed the NBN

Thumb mystery man on the phone

About James

I have lived a lot of years and the more years I have lived, the fewer answers i have found. I hope that by engaging here we can discover some answers together.

The NBN is a lemon. Here's how our Prime Minister hijacked a project that has fallen so far from the mark.

Kevin Rudd was a waste of a prime minister, but he was right about one thing: the importance of a national broadband network.

National Broadband Network.

National Broadband Network

The NBN, as it is now known, was potentially, as Rudd suggested, the most important infrastructure project since the Snowy Mountain Scheme. Given its reach and implications, I'd argue that it was more so.

Got an NBN horror story? Air your grievances with us. We're listening! 

While I am no expert, I have no doubt that Rudd and his Communications Minister, Stephen Conroy, got their estimates of the total cost wrong. With government projects, this is more often the case than not. They minimise initial political pain by being very optimistic.

I also have no doubt that Rudd and Conroy got the timing estimate wrong. I recall very few government projects that were completed within the forecast time and I know very few people who expect them to be.

But that is were the errors of Rudd and Conroy stop. 

The real disaster regarding the NBN was caused by the most disappointing Australian Prime Minister Australia of my lifetime, the then-Minister for Telecommunications Malcolm Turnbull.

In his effort to appear competent, and with a view to following his then leader Tony Abbott, Minister Turnbull replaced fibre to the home with fibre to the node.

In other words, rather than having the six-lane superhighway running directly into our homes and businesses, Turnbull decided that we should save time and money by stopping it just outside its destination and completing the journey with a one-lane gravel track.

As a result, the NBN is super-fast to the node down the street, but super-slow from there to the house or office -- significantly reducing, and/or eliminating, any benefit.

A report on the NBN released last week highlighted findings that the telecommunication companies will be unable to deliver high-speed internet services where there is not fibre to the home.

On that basis alone, the outcome should be logical to anyone. If you poor water down a thick pipe for 10 meters and then a thin pipe for the last two, it will come out at a rate and volume determined by the thinner pipe. It's not rocket science.

Now, underestimating the cost of the NBN, as Rudd and Conroy did, is not good. But the fact is, Turnbull also underestimated the cost and the budget is again blown. Furthermore – if it costs a little more and you get a good outcome, you will live with it. But thanks to Turnbull, Australia is getting an NBN that in addition to costing more than he predicted, is substandard.

If it, the NBN, cannot deliver what is promised, as so many consumers are finding, it doesn't matter how much it cost.

Underestimating the time frame, as Rudd and Conroy did, is not ideal, especially as this has a flow-on effect to costs and delays when consumers can benefit from what their taxes are paying for. 

But the fact is, Turnbull also underestimated the time involved in completing the project and when consumers do get it, they will be getting a substandard product.

If it, the NBN, cannot deliver what is promised, as so many consumers are finding it cannot, it really does not matter when it is finished.

What Turnbull did not tell us, is that he is a weak man. In his efforts to please his prime minister at the time and win some brownie points in the electorate, he sacrificed the most important infrastructure project in generations.

For the sake of political point scoring, Turnbull sold and delivered a solution that will fail to deliver the benefits promised, and will ultimately cost time, money, consumer confidence and lives.

Limiting the capacity for the medical profession to make full use of the benefits of a broadband system will cost lives.

Malcolm Turnbull still won't admit that he sold us all a lemon!!

Banner 1
| Your rating
No ratings yet

Related stories

Do you have a canny tip for saving money.

Share your money-saving hacks here

Everyone loves to save a dollar or two when they can. Do you have any money-saving tips to share with your YsFriends?

4 months ago
(Money & Business)
Because you're never too old to pursue your passion.

Your midlife career-switch advice is golden

Have you started a new business or pulled off a major career switch in midlife? We'd love to hear from you.

Ageing Money
4 months ago
(Money & Business)
Rejuvenate in Retirement.

6 ways to retire from work, not life


Are you ready for The Lifestyle Change? Retirement can be a more difficult adjustment than we realise.

Retirement Health Relationships Money Ageing
4 months ago
(Money & Business)
James Packer: born with a silver spoon in his mouth.

Bring back death duties for silver spooners

Why should the privileged offspring of Australia's elite inherit their billions tax-free? Let's level the playing field.

Business Ageing Money
5 months ago
(Money & Business)
Retirees have copped a rough time in recent years.

A new approach to retirement planning

I’m going to stick my neck out just a bit and say retirees have had a raw deal over the past couple of decades.

Ageing Retirement Money
5 months ago
(Money & Business)
Funeral directors prey on the vulnerable.

Funeral directors are blood-sucking leeches

Leveraging grief to up-sell expensive funerals to vulnerable families is a loathsome practise and must stop.

Money Business Community Family
5 months ago
(Money & Business)
Trickle-down economics my arse.

How big business is giving you the shaft

Are you battling to make ends meet thanks to stagnant wages and lack of jobs? Here's who's to blame.

Politics Social Issues Community Business Money
5 months ago
(Money & Business)
What impact will the eventual death of Queen Elizabeth have on us in Australia?.

What happens to us when the Queen dies?


As a part of the Commonwealth, the impact on Australia will be greater than you think.

UK Australia Community Social Issues Politics
5 months ago
(Money & Business)
Myer - no Harrods.

Good riddance to Myer's CEO!

And there are plenty more who should follow him. Don't these obscene executive salaries make you furious?

Business Money
5 months ago
(Money & Business)
New CBA CEO Matt Comyn.

Why 'banker' should start with a W

It's our fault that the big banks treat us with such contempt and arrogance. Time to hit back by taking our mortgages and...

Community Money Business
5 months ago
(Money & Business)

Message board

Derek, 14 days ago:
I am great
George, 14 days ago:
What's up Thomas?
George, 15 days ago:
Messages are now updated in real time on other browsers.
Thomas, 15 days ago:
Thomas, about 1 month ago:
DJC, about 1 month ago:
George, about 2 months ago:
Message board active from June 2018

Have your say!

Your Great Australians

Trending stories
When it comes to great bloggers you can connect with, this list has you covered.

20 mature bloggers worth following

Looking for Australian...

(Entertainment & Culture) Over 1 year ago
Drizzle some maple syrup and your pancakes with bacon are good to go.

Mapled pancakes with organic bacon

C'Mon! You know you want to...

(Epicure) About 1 year ago
Many people let desire for something, such as a god, colour their assessment of the evidence.

Try wishing upon a proven star

''Never let a wish become...

(Headlines) Over 1 year ago
She truly does love, honour and obey Jim.

Jim really does spank his wife often

Part two in the story of...

(Love & Relationships) 8 months ago
Suzuki's cute little Ignis SUV has a lot going for it.

Review: 2017 Suzuki Ignis GL and GLX

Japanese car maker Suzuki,...

(Pastimes) 12 months ago
Weekly Poll
Photographic memories
It's 35 years since the Ash Wednesday bushfires in South Australia and Victoria claimed 75 lives and more than 2500 buildings.