YspeopleExplore tab

America was never great

About Subversive

Do you have your own gripe with your local or state government? And what are the streets like in your part of town, in your home state?

If you'd like me to fire a rocket up them, or a shoddy business, I'm listening! You can email me here.

What on earth makes Americans think their nation was ever 'great'?

Donald Trump fought the recent US presidential election with the slogan: Make American Great Again.

America was never great.

America was never great. Pic: iStock

This slogan, while probably not pondered or analysed in any depth by those who voted for Donald Trump, has a number of assumptions at its foundation. The first is that there is a meaningful definition of great, while the second is that American was ever great.

Setting aside the fact that the second point is inextricably linked to the first and is, to a point, invalid if there is no way of defining great, I disagree strongly with both assumptions.

I don't believe any country can be described as great and I am sick to death of pandering politicians describing Australia as the greatest country on earth or an example of a great multiultural society – or, worse still, the greatest example of multiculturalism on earth.

We are not great. We just are.

We may try hard and we may seek greatness, but there is no evidence that we have ever achieved it.

Greatness, or claiming it, is all about emotions and saying what people want to hear.

Greatness has never been defined and there may be no country on earth where the residents do not think it is the greatest country on earth. Certainly, I have met very few people who do not believe that theirs is the greatest country on earth.

That said, few if any can offer an objective criterion for measuring greatness.

I have no idea how to measure greatness. For me, it is just an emotional nonsense notion.

As for America being great, well:

  • One-third of Americans live below the poverty line
  • It has a plummeting literacy rate
  • It has the highest rate of imprisonment in the world
  • It has the third-highest rate of execution in the world
  • It has gone into the Middle East eight times - and failed eight times
  • Of its presidents, 10% have been shot dead
  • Another 40,000 of its people are killed by gun shot each year
  • Along with China, It is the world’s biggest polluter
  • This list could go on for ages.

    What's more, and in reference to America becoming great AGAIN, most of these facts have not changed since World War II.

    So, when exactly was American the greatest country on earth?

    Is the greatness of the United States measured by some disgusting notion relating to its military might and the fact that it spends more on the military in a week than the world spends on education in a year?

    The notion that any country is the greatest on earth is bizarre!

    The notion that the United States was ever the greatest nation on earth is absurd!

    Have I got it wrong?

    Banner 1
    | Your rating
    No ratings yet

    Related stories

    His Holiness the Dalai Lama.

    The power of the null hypothesis

    I am a big subscriber to the null hypothesis, a scientific term suggesting there is no evidence available to you that enables...

    Over 1 year ago
    Why is the Church obsessed with sex? Picture: Shutterstock.

    The plebiscite and the Christian obsession with sex

    Why does this most natural of human pursuits cause so much division?

    LGBTI Politics Marriage Equality Australia
    Over 1 year ago
    Let's do this! Picture: Shutterstock.

    Calling out the Coalition For Marriage for what it is


    The Coalition For Marriage's action against the gay community this week is no different to an old-fashioned religious witch hunt.

    LGBTI Politics Marriage Equality Australia
    Over 1 year ago
    All power to a truthful ABC.

    Why One Nation's push against the ABC is wrong

    The ABC has a responsibility to report the facts, not a balanced view.

    Social Issues Politics Australia
    Almost 2 years ago
    What do you think of Australia day? Picture: ABC.

    Australia Day: Is January 26 appropriate?

    What are your thoughts on an appropriate date to celebrate Australia Day? Here are mine.

    Community Social Issues Politics Australia
    Almost 2 years ago
    Is prison an ineffective deterrent? Please share your thoughts with us.

    Why do we jail offenders?

    Retribution is not, and should not, be the primary purpose of imprisonment.

    Community Social Issues
    Almost 2 years ago
    United, we CAN make a difference to our world.

    Together, the over-50s can change the world


    I am an Australian over the age of 50. I believe together we must stand, or divided we will fall.

    Ageing Social Issues Politics Australia
    Almost 2 years ago
    Peter Finch in that rousing scene from Network.

    I'm as mad as hell. Come yell with me!

    It's time to stand up and tell our politicians that we are as mad as hell and not going to take it anymore.

    Movies Community Social Issues Politics
    Almost 2 years ago
    How can PM Malcolm Turnbull truly understand the average Australian? Picture: iStock.

    Does Malcolm Turnbull understand you?

    How can anyone truly understand you until they have walked a mile in your shoes?

    Social Issues Politics Australia
    Almost 2 years ago
    Wooden, and full of half-truths and tall tales .

    Political integrity? Pffft, you've got to be joking!

    Don't you just hate politicians who think you are too thick to realise they are just telling you what you want to hear?

    Social Issues Politics Australia
    Almost 2 years ago

    Message board

    Derek, 11 months ago:
    I am great
    George, 11 months ago:
    What's up Thomas?
    George, 11 months ago:
    Messages are now updated in real time on other browsers.
    Thomas, 11 months ago:
    Thomas, 12 months ago:
    DJC, 12 months ago:
    George, 12 months ago:
    Message board active from June 2018

    Have your say!

    Your Great Australians

    Trending stories
    When it comes to great bloggers you can connect with, this list has you covered.

    20 mature bloggers worth following

    Looking for Australian...

    (Entertainment & Culture) About 2 years ago
    They may be hideous, but geez, some toby jugs are valuable.

    Is your toby jug worth a fortune?

    Did you know that some of...

    (Nostalgia) 11 months ago
    JB Hi-Fi is on the money when it comes to customer service.

    JB Hi-Fi Vs Harvey Norman

    When it comes to comparing...

    (Money & Business) Over 2 years ago
    Baby Boomer men are having more unsafe sex than their younger counterparts.

    Why are many older men so stupid about sex?

    Baby Boomers are much more...

    (Love & Relationships) Over 1 year ago
    These brownies just get better with age.

    Rachel's 'liberated' brownies


    (Epicure) Almost 2 years ago
    Weekly Poll
    Photographic memories
    It's 35 years since the Ash Wednesday bushfires in South Australia and Victoria claimed 75 lives and more than 2500 buildings.